Astronauts. In 1959, before anyone had been to space, NASA actually went through the service records of more than 500 military test pilots, looking for a special particular kind of person, someone who could keep their heart rate steady while the aircraft came apart around them. Someone who could describe exactly what was in front of them precisely because their own life and everyone else's depended on that precision. And so with that, they chose seven. And over the decades that followed, the United States and the Soviet Union selected hundreds more by roughly the same standard. And over 70 years, a surprising number of them came home and said some version of the same thing. >> I saw something out there. I don't know what it was. It was a bogey. >> Seven, go ahead. >> Got bogey at 10:00 high. >> This is Houston. Say again, seven. >> Seven, a bogey at 10:00 high. >> Some said it once in a debriefing, and others mentioned it time and time again. Some of them changed their stories over the course of their lives, but it remains something that astronauts talked about. And one engineer from the Apollo era claimed that all of them were told to keep quiet. So folks, today we're going to go through all of them. Well, we're going to try to get through all of them. Every astronaut and cosmonaut I could find who reported something they couldn't identify. Like this video, subscribe, folks. And a quick word from our sponsors. This video is sponsored by Raycon. Folks, notice anything different about me? Oh. Oh, this? Oh. I'm glad you asked. These are the everyday clip earbuds by Raycon. And right now, Raycon's Black Friday sale is on. You can get up to 50% off everything on their site. Now, these are comfortable. These are This is I don't know how to endorse this. I like these very much. I've been using these pretty much every day. You go to the gym, you walk around. I can film stuff with them. I can get in the zone because they don't jam into your ear canal. They clip on. There I've never seen anything like this. And they're open ears, so I can still hear what's going on around me, which does matter, you know, if you're I don't know, walking in traffic. This it's good to have. Uh but the clip is made of nickel titanium memory metal. Same stuff they use in aerospace. Regular aerospace, not the alien. Well, maybe. Who knows? Uh they're super light, great if you wear glasses, by the way. They don't fall out, which is for me probably the biggest selling point. And they're multi-point, which means they jump between my phone and my laptop [music] without putting up a fuss. 8 hours of playtime, 30 with the case. I charge them about once a week. Raycon's got over 3 million customers and a 30-day guarantee if you don't love them. So scan the QR code or go to buyraycon.com/area52clip to get up to 50% off sitewide during Raycon's Black Friday sales. And grabbing a pair helps support the channel. Uh so thanks [music] Raycon for sponsoring this video. All right, we paid the bills. Folks, before we start, I do want to take a minute to talk about something that sits underneath this entire episode because I think this is the real meat and potatoes here. Almost everything you believe about the world you believe because someone told you. You never personally measured the distance to the sun or you've never uh seen an atom or visited most of the countries you're sure exist. And I'm sure they exist as well. Uh but philosophers have a name for this. It's called the epistemology of testimony. The Australian philosopher C. A. J. Cody wrote a whole book on it in the early '90s. And this argument uh roughly is that uh testimony isn't a weak form of knowledge sitting on top of the strong stuff. It's actually the foundation. Take it away and almost nothing is left, nothing that we know of. And what makes testimony trustworthy is usually a mix of three things, and this is very important. Is the witness competent, meaning trained to observe what they're describing? Are they sincere, meaning do they have any reason to lie or embellish? And do they have something to lose by saying it? Astronauts might be the strongest case of all three that we have. Competence goes without saying. These people are trained. They spend thousands of hours in simulators learning exactly what they should expect to see so they could recognize anything that didn't belong. And sincerity is a little harder to judge, but considering their incentives, their career is depended on being seen as the most rational people alive. So Scott Kelly, who spent almost a year in orbit, has described what happened to navy pilots who reported a UFO. Alien became their call sign and it stuck with them for their entire career. So a bit of a mockery there, which brings us to the third point. Every person in this episode risked something [music] by speaking. Some spoke anyway. Some spoke once and went silent and like I said, others broke their silence years later or reneged and went back on what they said. But now worried about where I'm coming from. I've been a magician for my entire adult life and my job is to sort of control what people see and what they remember afterwards. There's an old line in magic that scientists are the easiest audience to fool because they trust their own observations. Magicians know how malleable perception can be. And so I came into this with a specific question. What do we do with the testimony of people whose whole careers were built on the reliability of their own observations. Here's how this is going to go. We're going to go chronologically. About 25 people over the last 70 years, test pilots before NASA existed, then Mercury, Gemini, Apollo, Skylab, Soviet Space Station, and the present day. A A of the audio you're going to hear comes from these newly released tranches, hate that word, uh, that the Pentagon's been releasing, but they released a whole bunch of files and debriefings from astronauts, and we're going to go through some of that as well. A lot of YouTube videos. I actually have an exclusive rights to a Gordon Cooper interview, uh, that I purchased and that we're going to look at as well. But I don't want to make this about a government thing. It's not a government thing. It's about the people on those tapes, about the human beings [snorts] that went into space. And the stories get tremendously weird. Even a space shuttle surgeon who described something following his spacecraft that he could only compare to a snake, and the man who claimed they were all told to shut up. Let's begin. To understand how it starts for all the newcomers of the channel or to this topic, you need to understand how new the idea of like flying saucers were. So in June 24th, 1947, a pilot named Kenneth Arnold was flying near Mount Rainier in Washington State when he saw nine bright objects moving at a speed he estimated at well over 1,000 miles an hour. He told a reporter they moved like a saucer skipping across the water. He was describing how they moved, not their actual shape, but the headline the writer used turned into flying saucers, and within a few weeks the phrase was everywhere. In matter of fact, two weeks later, Roswell Army Airfield put out a press release saying it had recovered a flying disc. It retracted that claim the next day. The Air Force started an investigation in a series of projects with different code names. First Sign, then Grudge, and in 1952 Project Blue Book, and in January of '53 a panel convened by the CIA known as the Robertson panel recommended that the government work to reduce public interest in the subject and strip away its aura of mystery. And so by the early '50s, pilots including military pilots are reporting things they can't explain, and the institutions they report to are becoming actively [music] interested in making those reports seem less important. Sounds a little suspicious. And that, my friends, is the atmosphere which lands us here, where two future Mercury astronauts end up seeing something. So Deek Slayton, December 12th, 1951. He's a test pilot flying a P-51 Mustang near Minneapolis. Now at around 10,000 feet when he notices something ahead of him. >> It's like closed on this thing why didn't look like a a weather balloon and that's what I presumed it was. And I had plenty of gas and time so I decided I just come back around and make a make a pass on it. And uh I got around where I should have been coming back on this thing all of a sudden it didn't look like a balloon anymore. It looked like a a saucer sitting on the edge at a 45° angle. I didn't have any gun camera film on board unfortunately or I would have shot some pictures of it. And about that time I guess what whatever it was for whatever reason just took off climbing at about a 45° angle and and just accelerated and disappeared and I I obviously couldn't follow it with an old piston engine fighter. So uh I turned around and went home. >> So pay attention how this guy's mind works for a second in that account because it's a textbook example of disciplined observation. His first hypothesis is is uh a kite and then his second idea is that it's a weather balloon. And he [music] and he closes in to test it. And then he gets nearer and the object stops looking like a balloon and starts looking like a disc and then it climbs away at a steep angle, mind I add, very interesting and in his words flat disappears. Now this doesn't sound like a man who wants to see a flying saucer. It's like someone who's working through their own ontology and trying to explain, you know, what it is they're seeing until he runs out of ideas. And this gentleman ended up filing a report at the time through official channels. Most stories in this field get told for the first time years later after the fact. [music] Uh they don't get told when they happen and they certainly don't always get reported but Slayton's was on paper within days. And consider who this guy became because in 1959 he's selected as one of the Mercury Seven. And in 1962, I think a heart condition grounds him before he can fly. So, instead of leaving [music] NASA, he becomes director of flight crew operations. The man who decided which astronauts flew on which missions. And so for more than a decade, if you went to space as an American, Deke Slayton put you there. Including everyone who walked on the moon. And he finally flew himself in 1975 on the Apollo Soyuz test project at 51. So, the person who chose who went to the moon had himself chased a disk over Minnesota. 1951, the same year over West Germany, Gordon Cooper is flying an F-86 Sabrejet. Cooper will become the youngest of the Mercury Seven and the last American to orbit Earth alone. Here's what he said about what happened to him in Germany. >> Yes, they were flying quite high. How high we couldn't tell because we couldn't get anywhere near their altitude. But they were either very large craft way up or smaller craft still well above what we could get to. >> For a day and a half, all of this happened. But then no one wanted to talk about it. >> Well, we sent a report forward on it and and the answer that finally came back months later was they were probably high flying seed pods. Which didn't sound very logical. >> There are always a lot of excuses. There's always weather balloons. I've heard that one before. In 1951, you couldn't even get close to the things that were flying overhead. You or anyone else that was flying. >> were faster, higher. >> Metallic saucer-shaped objects at high altitude over several days. And they could outmaneuver the fighters sent after them. Cooper told this story consistently for the rest of his life. Six years later, Cooper is at Edwards Air Force Base in the Mojave Desert. It was the most important flight test center in the world. The X-1 broke the sound barrier there. The rocket planes, the experimental jets, the aircraft whose existence was absolutely classified at the time, all of them flew over that dry lake bed. It was a place where seeing something in the sky that you couldn't recognize was like par for the course. Every that was just part of the job because anything unusual over Edwards might be one of ours. So Cooper is managing a project out on the lake bed and he's got a camera crew filming equipment, apparently. Uh they come back and tell him they just filmed something land. >> As they were sitting there filming, a little saucer came from I say a little saucer, it was a saucer came flying over their heads, put down three little landing gear and landed right out on the dry lake bed. And they picked up their cameras and started over toward it filming as they went. And when they got in fairly close to it, it lifted up, put the gear back in the wheel wells, tipped up and took off at a great rate of speed. And so they brought the came into my office and told me what had happened and I sent them over to develop the film. And then had to go through the all the proper regulations of reporting this and and we wound up having to send the film forward to Washington and they uh base jet airplane and uh I don't know whether anyone's ever seen it since. >> Now the vehicle that you just described, how similar was it to the very first sighting that you had back in 1951? >> Quite similar. It was basically the same planform vehicle. They were double saucer, lenticular. But if you're going to be going in and out of atmospheres like Earth or other places might have, you certainly need a little more aerodynamic type of vehicle. And the saucer has the capability of going through the air at tremendous rates of speed and handling the bow and trailing wave without making shock wave. So it could be very silent while traveling at big rates of speed through the atmosphere. >> He describes a craft settling on the lake bed and his crew was filming it as it lifted off again. He says he held that film up to a window and saw it himself. Then it was sent to Washington and he never saw it again. I mean, what? Cooper didn't witness the landing himself, obviously, but the crew did. And what Cooper saw was the film. And that doesn't make the story any less credible in my opinion. This is still a very credible person who talks about this, but it makes it a different kind of story about evidence that existed and then kind of disappeared into an institution, which we've heard about time and time again, namely the Holloman landing footage as well. I digress. A few months after that, October 1957, the Soviets launch Sputnik and everything changes. The sky stops being a place where you test aircraft and becomes the front line of the Cold War. February 1962, John Glenn, the first American to orbit Earth. He looks out and sees these little glowing specks all around the capsule, and he calls them fireflies. You can actually hear his reaction to these on one of the latest releases from the Pentagon. Have a listen. >> They lit up like they were luminescent. I've never saw anything like it. They're around a little They're coming by the capsule uh and they look like little stars, a whole shower of them coming by. Uh they swirl around the capsule and go in front of the window and they're all brilliantly lighted. Uh they've probably averaged maybe uh 7 or 8 ft apart, but I can see them all down below me also. >> May 24th, 1962, Scott Carpenter on the Aurora 7 sees something similar. >> I have the more of the white particles in view below the capsule. They appear to be traveling exactly my speed. There is one drifting off. I haven't seen the great numbers of these particles, but I've seen uh a few of them. Their motion is random. They look exactly like snowflakes to me. >> He calls them snowflakes, >> white particles that look like snowflakes. Now, in October 1962, Wally Schirra also mentions this. >> the little white objects that seem to come from the capsule itself and drift off due to the particle there pointing on up John described it as a laved shaving. It's very good description of it. >> He called them little white objects. And then once again on May 15th, 1963, this time Gordon Cooper in space and he's on the final Mercury flight, 22 orbits. Have a listen. >> And I am observing John's fireflies drifting away from me. I can see some of them considerable distance out to the rear. Fireflies appear to be white very whitish with almost a green like real fireflies. >> So he calls them John's fireflies, obviously referring to John Glenn's description of these tiny particles. Now, NASA has since come out and sort of debunked or at least clarified what these objects might be. Most of them are just like particles from the thruster or bits of paint coming off of the actual capsule or perhaps things that were released into space from inside the capsule. I thought I'd mention it here anyways because a lot of confusion comes up around these particular audio tapes. They're all kind of describing the same thing. In my opinion, these are just probably space particles and are therefore debunked. But I think it's important to talk about the things that can be explained because it then shines a really bright light on the things that can't be explained. [music] So Mercury, if you're not familiar, it proved a human being could survive in orbit. Gemini was about learning to work there. It was a two-person crew, missions lasting up to two weeks, spacewalks, rendezvous, docking. And for this next story, for the first time, there are two witnesses in the same spacecraft. June 1965, Gemini 4, Ed White has just made the first American spacewalk and he's asleep. The commander, Jim McDivitt, is awake at the window, and as they pass over the Pacific near Hawaii, he sees something he can't identify. A white cylinder with an arm or pole extending from one end. So he grabs a camera and takes a picture. Then the other camera and takes another. Then fires his thrusters because for a moment he thinks they might actually collide. Years later, he summed it up like this. I said there was something out in front of me or outside the spacecraft that I couldn't identify and I've never been able to identify it. And I don't think anyone ever will. The ability to live with uncertainty and mystery without reaching irritably for an answer. That's what McDivitt is showing here. He doesn't claim that it was an alien or a UFO or some, you know, wild, extravagant craft. He doesn't claim anything at all. He's an engineer who saw something and tried to document it and conclude that the answer just might simply be out of his reach and out of his vocabulary. Six months later, Gemini 7, Frank Borman and Jim Lovell on a 14-day flight that was partly a medical experiment. Could two people for two weeks live in a space about the size of a front seat of a small car? Not something I'd want to find out, but probably stinky. All right. >> Loud and clear. 7, go ahead. >> This is Houston. Say again, 7. >> Roger. Gemini 7, is that the booster or is that an actual sighting? >> Do you have any more information, estimate distance or size? >> Actually, we also have the booster in sight. >> Understand you also have the booster in sight, Roger. >> Borman reports a bogey. Now, mission control's first question is whether it's the booster, right? Obviously, that's probably what it is. Like the spent upper stage of their own rocket, which is the obvious candidate. And the answer is that yes, they can see the booster. It's over there. What they're reporting is something else. So, 11 days into that mission, another spacecraft arrives, Gemini 6 with Wally Schirra and Tom Stafford. The two capsules meet in orbit and fly within a few feet of each other. It's the first rendezvous in history. Four human beings in two separate machines parked side by side at 17 and 1/2 thousand miles an hour. Before heading home, Schirra calls mission control. >> We have two might six. >> Then over the radio, Schirra plays jingle bells on a small harmonica he smuggled aboard. So, while Stafford rings a set of sleigh bells, they're the first musical instruments ever played in space, and both of them are in the Smithsonian right now. It's a lovely moment, and it tells you something about these men. Under enormous pressure, they still made room for a joke. One more from Gemini. It isn't in the Pentagon release though, and I don't know why, because it's one of the most interesting cases from the whole program. This one, this one blew me away. September 1966, Gemini 11, Pete Conrad and Dick Gordon. During the flight they spot a yellow orange object some distance away that seemed to hold position relative to them, and they start calling it the Wingman. And they take three photographs, and they're not great. Here are the photos. But this case it's complicated because it's about measurement and misidentification. So the official identification from NORAD was that it was a Soviet satellite called Proton 3, about 450 km away. So Bruce uh Macabee Macabee, Macabee, Macabee. Bruce Macabee um he was like the photographic expert at the time, and he analyzed these photos and determined that there's no way by multiple variables and measurements that this was that Russian satellite. And if you guys want to check out that file, it's I think it's like 19 pages long. I'll leave it in the description where you can check it out yourself, but it literally doesn't agree with what NORAD said, and it makes a pretty strong case. And I think we're going to get back to that case in a minute because something else happens on the Gemini 11 eventually. Uh a photo appears, a contested photo that seems to be a giant UFO hovering over the Earth, a photo potentially taken by NASA. And this case was kind of shelved for 50 years. Again, very surprised I didn't include this in in the latest tranche. Tranche, tranche. Three years later, Conrad and Gordon flew to the moon together on Apollo 12. Let's go to Apollo. Apollo is pretty amazing when you think about it because they created something that had never existed in human history. They created a place where a human being, think about this, could be completely unobservable. Every human being before 1968 lived within reach of other humans. Even the most isolated explorer at the South Pole or at the bottom of the sea was on the same planet under the same sky, but when Apollo spacecraft goes behind the moon, the entire mass of the moon sits between the crew and every other person who has ever lived. No radio, no tracking, no one watching for about 45 minutes of every 2-hour orbit. They are completely alone. NASA called it loss of signal. All right, Christmas Day 1968, Apollo 8, Frank Borman, Jim Lovell, and Bill Anders are the first people to leave Earth's orbit and circle another world on Christmas morning on the far side of the moon and out of contact. They fire the engine that will bring them home. If it fails, they're stranded in lunar orbit forever. Thankfully, it works. They come around the edge of the moon and the signal returns and Lovell says this. >> Roger. Please be informed there is a Santa Claus. >> A Christmas joke from a crew that has just done something no human being has ever done. May 1969, Apollo 10, the full dress rehearsal for the landing. Things are getting pretty exciting. Tom Stafford, John Young, and Gene Cernan fly all the way to the moon and take the lunar module down to within about 15 km of the surface. Everything short of landing. On the far side in the radio shadow, the crew hears a strange whistling in their headsets. It lasts about an hour and Cernan calls it outer space type music. >> Yeah, it sounds like you know outer space type music. >> Two months later, Apollo 11, the landing everyone remembers. On the way out Buzz Aldrin sees a light out the window that seems to be moving along with them. He's always been clear that he doesn't believe it was an alien spacecraft. >> And we can look out these windows and and see the earth drift by and see the moon drift by. >> did you see? >> And I saw a light out there. Okay? This is after we had witnessed the upper stage rocket uh next to us make an evasive maneuver to miss the moon. So we very shrewdly, Neil did, said Houston where is the upper stage? And they didn't know right away but they said we'll check with the guys in the back room. The guys in the back room in 10 minutes came back and said it's 6,000 miles away. Well we figured that's not what we're looking at. So we started thinking a little bit more about these four panels and I'd seen a a graph where it showed the separation distance that was calculated before liftoff, before the whole mission went of of where these panels would be. >> What did you see? >> What did I see during the flight? >> Yeah, you saw >> one of the four panels, the 99.999 and these are three guys who have flown in space twice and have looked out at the stars and all sorts of things. So believe believe yes, we certainly saw something. We could see uh look at it in a second. So it was one of the panels yeah. >> All right, Apollo 12 November 1969 Conrad and Gordon, the pair who photographed the wingmen on Gemini 11. So now with Alan Bean, their medical debriefing is in the Pentagon and all three described the same thing, flashes and streaks of light in the dark while they tried to sleep. >> Somebody reported on one of the earlier flights that some guy up I got the letter to the Lord somewhere, and they sent it down to me at the cape about two days where the VHF radio noises would could be discharged from, and the other ones were. Well, I thought it was my old flight at night when their eyes supposed They they they noticed them when they were awake at night. The spacecraft was dark, and they thought they were in a spacecraft. >> Apollo 14 crew described them too in a debriefing released this July. >> Once I saw were very sharp. There was no mistaking what it was. It was a streak so long instantaneously disappeared. >> Yeah, I think that's correct. Both the single streak and the double shots appeared to be very clear to me. >> Apollo 16 in April 1972 appears in the files as well. It was just a flash and and the way I happened to notice it I was looking at a at a horizon that was showing up from solar corona or zodiacal light whatever you want to call it in that region. It was very shortly after we lost the signal from Earth. And then December 1972 Apollo 17 the last time human beings went to the moon, allegedly. Gene Cernan is back for his second trip with Harrison Schmitt, a geologist and the only professional scientist ever to walk on the moon by the way, and Ron Evans in the command module. The Pentagon's file on this mission is the most substantial in the release because it describes three separate stretches of reported phenomena about 9 minutes on the first day, 3 hours on the second, and 6 minutes on the third. >> A few very bright particles or fragments or something that go drifting by as we went over. >> There was a whole bunch of big ones out my window, as a matter just bright. Looks like before the July >> They described bright fragments near the spacecraft, angular, jagged pieces drifting past the window, catching the light. >> And now you can see some of them in shape. They're very jagged angular fragments or tumbling. Looks like pieces of something uh All right. >> And there's also a story about Bob Evans that I'd never heard until I researched this episode. And it's secondhand, so take it for what it's worth, but it comes from Joanne Donaldson who says she worked at NASA as a biomedical engineer. And while Cernan and Schmitt were on the surface, Evans was orbiting alone, passing into the loss of signal behind the moon every 2 hours according to Donaldson. When he came back into radio range, CAPCOM asked if he was lonely up there, and Evans said, no. I got company. Whatever that means. >> Day two, Ron came out from behind the moon, reported in to mission control, and Gene comes up on the comm lake and says, hey Ron, you're not lonely up there without us, are you? And Ron reported back, says, no, I got company. We were all told we're going to continue on with the mission as if nothing has happened. And do not discuss this anomaly with anyone outside of your command. >> In her account, the public audio feed was cut and staff were told to carry on as though nothing had happened and not to discuss it outside the team. She also says Evans later described a cigar-shaped object roughly 40 ft long orbiting the moon. Hearsay? I don't know, but still, these cigars, by the way, keep popping up in space. It's like the mothership and we get to see like the discs down here and the I don't know, just a but that's kind of what it seems like. I couldn' find a recording of that exchange that she's talking about, but only her account exists, but notice where it happens. It's always on the far side of the moon and the radio shadow, the one place a human being could truly be alone. After Apollo came Skylab, America's first space station. It was built from the unused Saturn V upper stage, the same kind of rocket stage that carried the Apollo crew toward the moon. Three crews lived aboard in 1973 and 1974 and excerpts from all three debriefings were in this Pentagon's first release. On the second crew, Jack Lousma reports a large red object out the window. He compares it to a star, but far brighter than Jupiter. And on the final crew, Commander Gerald Carr reports flashing lights outside the station, and he's specific that they were moving relative to Skylab. And that, folks, is the end of the Apollo era, more than a decade of American human space flight and almost every single stage, someone at the window described something they couldn't account for, which brings us to the man who says he knows why none of it went any further. Our ancestors came from outer space. All right, the guy I promised you at the beginning of the video, Maurice Chatelain, a French-born engineer, moves to the US in 1955 and ends up at Ryan Electronics, a NASA contractor running a research group. And he's got 11 patents, including a radar landing system used on the Ranger and Surveyor missions to the moon. But his book cover calls him the NASA scientist who designed and built the Apollo communications system. Now, a lot of UFO writers call him NASA's chief of communications, but what's really on paper is that he was a serious engineer, NASA contractor during the Apollo era. And in 1979, he writes this. All Apollo and Gemini flights were followed, both at a distance and sometimes quite closely by space vehicles of extraterrestrial origin. Every time it occurred, the astronauts informed mission control, who then ordered absolute silence. Absolute silence. But the year before in 1978, Gordon Cooper writes a letter to the United Nations. He says he believes the vehicles and their crews are visiting from other planets. So by the late '70s, you've got a Mercury astronaut writing to the UN and an Apollo era engineer saying that silence was ordered. And then in the '80s, the story moves to the other side of the Iron Curtain. Now the Soviet space program ran in parallel with NASA's for three decades, but under a completely different relationship with secrecy. So in the Soviet system, failures weren't reported. Crews were sometimes announced only after launch. So most of what we know about the Soviet sightings reached the West very late and secondhand and through translation and that type of thing. So it isn't it isn't as easy as just FOIA requesting something. Right, 1981, aboard the Salyut 6 space station, cosmonaut Vladimir Kovalyonok describes looking out a porthole and seeing an object he couldn't explain. He said it seemed impossible according to the laws physics. Now that account survives only in print through translations and later retellings. I couldn't find him retelling it on camera. 10 years later, the Soviet space program has a new station, Mir. And in December 1990, two cosmonauts launched toward it on Soyuz TM 11, Musa Manarov and Viktor Afanasyev. They'll spend 5 months in orbit. When they launch, the Soviet Union exists, and by the end of the following year, it's gone. These two men are orbiting the planet while the country that sent them is quietly coming apart underneath them. And from that one crew come two of the best known cosmonaut accounts there are. So first, Afanasyev. I'd rather you hear it from him. >> I think that we are not alone in the universe. I believe that someone or something of extraterrestrial origin has visited Earth. >> In April of 1979, cosmonaut Viktor Afanasyev lifted off from Star City to dock with the Soviet Salyut 6 space station. But while in route, something strange happened. Cosmonaut Afanasyev saw an unidentified object turn toward his craft and begin tailing it through space. >> It followed us during half of our orbit. We observed it on the light side, and when we entered the shadow side, it disappeared completely. It was an engineering structure made from some type of metal, approximately 40 m long with inner holes. The object was narrow here and wider here, and inside there were openings. Some places had projections like small wings. The object stayed very close to us. We photographed it, and our photos showed it to be 23 to 28 m away. >> In addition to photographing the UFO, Afanasyev continually reported back to mission control about the craft's size, its shape, and position. When the cosmonaut returned to Earth, he was debriefed, told never to reveal what he knew, and had his cameras and film confiscated. Those photos and his voice transmissions from space have never been released. >> If you've come across this story before, it was probably dated 1979 on the way to Salyut 6, but Afanasyev's first space flight was this one in December 1990 to Mir. And somewhere along the way, the story got attached to the wrong decade and the wrong station, and the mistake has just been copied over and over again. But trust me, I'm going to go with the flight he was actually on. Now, his crewmate in March 1991 on the same mission, Musa Manarov, reportedly filmed this from Mir. Have a look. What are we doing here? Is this disclosure? Are we doing it today? All right. Two men, one spacecraft, one mission. One talks about an object close enough to be photographed, and the other brings home the actual footage. We can't know if they're describing the same thing, but they were up there together looking out the same windows. Okay, 1995. Now it gets weird, if it wasn't already. The Snake Story Musgrave has one of the most extraordinary careers in the history of space flight. Six missions from '83 to '96, the only astronaut to fly on all five space shuttle orbiters, a former marine, a trauma surgeon, and the holder of a remarkable number of academic careers. [music] In 1993, he was one of the spacewalkers who repaired the Hubble Space Telescope in orbit, which you could argue was the most delicate manual work any human has ever done in space. This guy is pretty credible, and in '95, Musgrave went on a television series called Sightings and described something he'd seen on Hold on. Two separate missions. Roll the tape. >> Um two of my missions, and I still don't have an answer. Um I have seen a a snake out there, 6, 7, 8 ft long. It is rubbery because it has internal waves in it, and it follows you for a rather long period of time. The more you fly in space, the more you see an incredible amount of things out there. And that sort of brings to you really a certainty that that other living creatures are out there. Some incredibly primitive, more primitive than some is just just proteins coming together, amino acids, and some just single celled organisms, and other civilizations have been around for a million years that are doing unimaginable kinds of things. >> So he described it as a snake, a slippery snake, 6 to 8 ft long with a rubbery quality and waves moving through it. It followed the spacecraft for a long time. He also said that what he saw in space left him convinced there's other life out there. Now, I've read a lot of Musgrave's interviews and he's a complicated witness in the best [music] sense. He's careful and he's measured and well-tempered, but he's also said he doesn't believe the government is hiding UFO information. Like he isn't selling anything and that's exactly why his description stands out. Like he's kind of saying UFOs, I don't think they're being hidden by the government, but also I've seen snakes in space. Also sounds like a terrible horror movie, which I must see. Snakes in Space II coming soon. In 1999, Gordon Cooper did a series of interviews, multiple interviews you could say. He's got some loose lips. He likes to talk about UFOs and aliens. And one of those interviews I came across at an auction. This one here. If you guys want to check out the entire interview, I'll upload it for members. I'm not going to post it here because it is a bit lengthy, [music] but you guys can check that out. It gets really interesting because he talks about not only the sightings he had as a pilot, not only the craft that he saw landing or the letter that he wrote to the UN, but also the reason why other astronauts aren't talking about their sightings. >> Um unlike yourself, I guess, do you think there are any other astronauts who may have had similar experiences with extraterrestrial craft. >> Yes, I know one or two have. Unfortunately, when you say astronauts have had contact, people think you're you're having it in in space. In space, to my knowledge, McDivitt was the only one that could be, you know, possibly an unidentified object. And other than that, all these stories that were made up and sold to people like Nightland Choir and so on were totally fictitious. And I had I've had any number of things written up about and reported by me of conversations I've had with extraterrestrials while on orbit and sightings that I had in orbit I was told to shut up about all these kind of things that were made strictly to make money on print. >> What what happened to James McDivitt? I mean, do you know or >> Well, he never could determine what it really was. The sun was glinting so on this metallic object so brightly you really couldn't tell from the pictures what it was or wasn't. And he never saw it again, so no one to this day knows. But there have been other astronauts who've had contact from a, you know, flying airplanes. So uh >> Um why don't you think they've come forward? I mean, is it some they just don't want to talk about or >> Well, maybe they think there's not really that much to talk about yet to get contacted by somebody. >> I mean, since you've seen one of these objects, I mean, do you think mankind is ready for such an incident now or >> I think mankind is really pretty much ready for this now. I don't There may be isolated cases of hysteria and they're hyped and built up, but I think man on earth here is pretty much ready to uh to receive man from somewhere else. Yes, I do believe in UFOs. I believe that there there's too many other places that people could habitate, on the planets, do not be none on be habitable. And I believe that I believe that they're coming here to visit us on occasion or coming here for whatever reason they're coming here. >> October 2003 Yang Liwei becomes the first person China sends to space alone aboard the Shenzhou V. At some point during the flight he hears knocking on the hull. He later compared it to someone hitting an iron bucket with a wooden hammer. He looked out the porthole and saw nothing. And according to Yang, crews on later Chinese missions heard it too. It's one door you don't want to answer. Just don't answer that door. Don't open the hatch. So there's a subtle point about physics here as well because sound can't travel through the vacuum outside. Like space is silent. So any sound Yang heard had to travel through the structure of the spacecraft itself, which means something was physically in contact with the hull. The hull itself was doing something, right? I don't know. I'm not a scientist. Now think about where he was. First person in his country's history to leave the planet completely alone in a sealed capsule and you hear knocking. Are you What are you doing? I'm soiling my little space suit. That's what I'm doing. Immediately change my pants cuz that is the most terrifying thing. Like there's I don't think you could write like a short horror story that is scarier than that. Regardless. In 2005 on the International Space Station Commander Leroy Chiao is on a spacewalk 230 miles up doing 17,000 miles an hour and five lights go by him in formation. >> We were on a spacewalk to install navigation antennas outside of the International Space Station. We were in that transition zone part of the orbit where we're going from night to day and right at that moment I saw what looked like five lights flying in formation and kind of an inverted check mark. There was no time to take a picture of it. It just happened in just a couple of seconds then we burst into sunrise and everything was gone. >> Now he says his heart leapt into his throat. I can't imagine but when you're on a spacewalk like you're one broken tether away from floating off into a dark abyss forever. So for some reason I tend to believe this guy. In 2008 Edgar Mitchell on the Apollo 14 he's the sixth man to walk on the moon. He grew up in Roswell and he goes on a UK rock radio station and says this. >> I happened to be privileged enough to have been on the fact that we have been visited on this planet. And the UFO phenomenon is real although it's been covered up by our government for quite a long time. >> We have been visited. I mean Now this isn't firsthand information. This is him saying that people in the military and intelligence circles [music] gave him this information but I still think that's quite pertinent. And in 2023 Scott Kelly who's got four space flights and a year in space at NASA's own public UFO meeting tells a story from his fighter pilot days. His radar officer was convinced they'd just flown past a UFO but Kelly himself didn't see it. >> And my RIO Fought the guy who was sitting in the back of the Tomcat was convinced we flew by a UFO. It turns out it was a balloon. >> Now before we move on I do want to come back to something that I thought was very interesting. So I have a book called the Simpkinson NASA Archive by Ed Wilson. This book is solely dedicated to a Gemini 11 photograph that was found hidden buried in an auction. Was like this lithograph or this print and I'll pull it up here of a UFO a flying saucer hovering over the earth with the caption, strange object as seen by the Gemini 11 crew. This thing is absolutely wild. I can't get it out of my head. I wonder today if this is real. You know, this was amongst real photos and Gemini 11 was also the same flight where those other astronauts took photos. And so I wonder if that is the same thing. And it's funny how no one kind of pulled that together until now. I just thought that was really interesting. Now, my conviction on the Simpkinson archive UFO photo, which isn't really public like a lot of people don't know about this thing but my conviction is fairly low that this is a real picture. Although in the book he does a lot of tests and, you know, runs it through all types of, you know, rigorous, I don't know, testing and determines that it's authentic and by, by so many different things, but I I... I don't know if I buy it, because the caption as seen by to me signals that this is a reproduction of something that they saw. Now, on that Gemini 11 flight, there was a flight log of them also seeing something anomalous, which we talked about earlier. So I wonder if this photo was just the illustrator's sort of um embellishment or I guess artistic freedom that he took in order to depict what it is they might have seen. Uh a strange object during the Gemini 11 flight. Now, the photo that's under this UFO as well, uh which is the photo of Earth, I think exists without the UFO. So that UFO would have had to appear and disappear within about a 90-second frame of time. So again, it's very complicated. The photo is very cool and just the idea that this NASA engineer would have this hidden away is very strange to me. Either it's like some prank, some inside joke, like a birthday card, [music] or I don't know what. It's just and I, you know, I don't know if we'll ever get the answer to that. I just thought it was really interesting and worth mentioning. Um and the next thing I want to mention before we talk about the final photo here is the Artemis II flight. I don't know if you folks remember the Artemis II flight, but this I followed this thing in its entirety. It was beautiful. It was amazing to see uh these pilots, you know, working together, becoming the best of friends, flying around the moon, coming home, landing in the ocean. And then they get a meeting with Donald Trump in the Oval Office, and somebody, I think Donald Trump mentioned something about the UFOs or the UAP, [music] and the one pilot just shoots the other pilot this glance like kind of like you know, like one of these. >> They saw things that you wouldn't believe, so >> And I just can't get that out of my head. I feel like they've seen something as well. It seems like every single pilot, every single astronaut has a story to tell, which brings us to this last photo. Three points of light. What is this? Okay, so this was taken during Apollo 17 in December of 1972, and it sat in NASA's archive for decades. And when the Pentagon released it in May, uh it it came in with a note, and the note says there's no consensus on what the photograph shows, and that early analysis suggested depicts a physical object. What? The Department of War opened a case on it, and that's kind of where we're at right now. I don't know where that's going. I don't like the idea that they're like, here's this, we don't know what it is, what do you think? Like you I don't know. You're the one with stuff in the space. You You tell us what it is. But I just think it's interesting that the last photo, so a photo from the Sorry, the last human mission to the moon in a public archive for 54 years, and in 2026, you know, the United States military formally opened an inquiry into it. I don't know if that's just for social credit or for I I don't know. But when I started this episode, I I kind of just expected to end up with a list and sort of a catalog of claims; and what it seems to be more of is a pattern. And that, across 70 years, across two rival space programs, across people with every professional reason to stay quiet, the same thing keeps popping up. A trained observer looks at a window, sees something and has to decide, do I tell people? Do I not tell people? And then the people who you told have to decide, do we release it? And some reported it right away and others it went into a file, some apparently made it into a joke and some waited decades and some told, you know, the public. A lot of them reached for the nearest words that they could think of describing these objects, a snake, a beer can, you know, a firefly, what have you. But remember the three questions. Is the witness competent? Are they sincere? And did they have something to lose by speaking? By all three standards, it's really hard to imagine better witnesses than the people in this episode. I don't know what else to say on this topic, folks. I'm going to throw the ball over at you. If there's something that I missed in terms of astronaut testimony, there's just so I was surprised going through all of this just how much came up and I actually wouldn't be surprised at this point if more popped up after this episode. Uh but please let me know. Follow the conversation over on Discord if you want. We got an active community there that's ready and willing to chat about this stuff. And one last thing. Let me know if you guys want to talk about the moon because recently, and I had a hard time finding this anywhere else, someone sent me footage of what allegedly was buildings on the moon and astronauts walking through them. I don't know what to make of this footage, whether it's real or not. Uh I found traces of this footage decades ago on the internet. And so therefore not AI. Um but could it be fake in some other way? Potentially. But if not, this could this be more proof that there are structures on the moon and that they have seen it? Um I've got some more information about the moon stuff that I'd love to share with you guys. And if that's an episode you guys would be interested in, let me know in the comments and we'll see you on the next video. Peace and love. [music] [music]