Skip to main content

[@ChrisWillx] Why Are There 0 Gay Football Players? - Peter Crouch

· 5 min read
[@ChrisWillx] Summarizer
Video Bot

@ChrisWillx - "Why Are There 0 Gay Football Players? - Peter Crouch"

Link: https://youtu.be/RHKiynVPXn8

Short Summary​

The video discusses the lack of openly gay male Premier League players despite statistical probabilities suggesting there should be several. It explores potential reasons for this discrepancy, including pressures to focus on the game and concerns about potential distractions or negative repercussions, acknowledging that while support for openly gay players is likely present, perceived or real barriers still exist.

Key Quotes​

Here are four direct quotes from the transcript that I found to be particularly insightful:

  1. "Currently, zero active Premier League male players are publicly out as gay. Statistically speaking, there should be 20 to 35. Same in La Liga, same in the German league, same in the French league. And there is one gay guy in Syria in Italy. Why?" This quote highlights the stark disparity between the expected number of openly gay players and the reality, raising a crucial question about the reasons behind this discrepancy.

  2. "There is evidently something true or not that is lingering to cause those players. It's almost 100% a guarantee that there are that there is not no gay players, right, in the Premier League." This emphasizes the near certainty of gay players existing in the Premier League while also highlighting the existence of some inhibiting factor, real or perceived, that prevents them from coming out.

  3. "I think footballers just want to get on with playing and do something they love and done since they were a kid and that potentially could be a distraction. So, if there are people out there that, you know, don't feel that they want to come out that then that's totally fine as well." This quote provides a player's perspective, acknowledging the potential for being openly gay to become a distraction from their professional lives and respecting the decision of players who choose not to come out.

  4. "Interesting. We were saying before about how um previously there was a disadvantage because you didn't have uh direct route to be able to broadcast what it is that you've got going on. Uh and in many ways that was a weakness, but now that it's an availability, there's almost this sense of like entitlement or obligation. It's like, well, tell me tell me what you've got going on. Is that a new car? What happened with the dog? Has the dog has it? Like how's the dog doing? You know, has it been spayed yet? Like there's this uh necessity for everything to be keeping up with the Kardashians." This addresses how social media has created a new pressure for athletes to share personal details, contrasting that with the view of athletes as people who don't have an "obligation" to share their personal lives.

Detailed Summary​

Here's a detailed summary of the YouTube video transcript, presented in bullet points:

Main Topic: The absence of openly gay male players in the Premier League and other elite sports.

Key Arguments and Points:

  • Statistical Anomaly:
    • Given the number of players in the Premier League (around 600-650 active players per season, potentially 2000-3000 over a decade), statistically, there should be 20-35 openly gay players.
    • The same discrepancy exists in other major leagues like La Liga, Bundesliga, and Ligue 1.
  • Support in Dressing Rooms:
    • One speaker believes that if a Premier League player came out as gay, they would be well-supported by teammates.
    • They acknowledge that there might be "idiots" in the crowd (similar to racism issues), but overall, acceptance within the team is thought to be high.
  • Personal Experiences and Considerations:
    • One speaker played with Thomas Hitzlsperger, who came out as gay after retiring. Hitzlsperger felt he couldn't come out during his playing career, but has been well-supported since.
    • Players may choose not to come out due to the desire to concentrate on football, potential distractions, and uncertainty about the fallout.
  • The "Class Thing" Theory:
    • It's questioned whether the lack of openly gay players in the Premier League might be related to the sport's historical association with the working class, compared to sports like rugby, cricket, and tennis.
  • Focus on Professionalism:
    • It is raised that players might simply want to focus on their job and not feel obligated to share their personal life or sexuality.
  • Potential Distraction:
    • The possibility that coming out could be a distraction from the job of playing football is considered.
  • Pride and Acceptance Paradox:
    • While there's visible support for LGBTQ+ rights (e.g., brands changing logos for Pride Month), this doesn't seem to translate into openly gay representation in elite sports.
  • Shifting Expectations and Obligations:
    • There's discussion about how the rise of social media and personal branding has created a sense of obligation to share personal details, which may pressure some players.
  • Analogies to Personal Sharing:
    • The conversation touches upon how sharing personal life details (e.g., cars, dogs, family events) has become commonplace, blurring the lines between public and private life.
  • Monumental Moment:
    • It is expressed that it would be a monumental moment when a Premier League player does come out.